Max and Leo's Pizza Newton

Max and Leo's Pizza Newton is a standout gem nestled in the heart of Newton, MA, where authentic American-style and Italian-influenced pizzas come alive through masterful craftsmanship and heartfelt passion. This cozy pizza restaurant and bar exudes charm with its intimate setting—featuring seating at a bar-height counter, a few small tables tucked in the corner, and an open kitchen showcasing the fiery coal oven at the center of it all.

Step inside, and the inviting aroma of coal-fired crust and fresh tomato sauce immediately teases your senses. Max and Leo's specialty lies in their perfectly balanced pizzas—not too thick, not too thin, but impeccably handmade with love. Their menu highlights are a testament to their culinary expertise, featuring crowd-pleasers like the classic Pepperoni Pizza, the fresh and fragrant Margherita Pizza adorned with basil, and the delightfully savory Buffalo Chicken Pizza. Each bite offers a beautifully textured crust, bubbling mozzarella, and toppings that burst with robust flavor, echoing the dedication poured into every pie.

But the magic doesn’t stop at pizza. Fans rave about creative starters like the Coal Fired Nachos and the intensely flavorful Crab Dip. Their Oven Roasted Wings are a sensory delight —whether it’s the Charred Honey Hot Habanero wings drizzled with wildflower honey or the Lemon Rosemary wings topped with caramelized onions, these succulent wings offer layers of heat, sweetness, and aromatic depth that truly elevate the dining experience.

For those seeking something a little different, the Eggplant Parm Calzone and the hearty Meatball Sandwich provide comforting Italian-American flavors that linger fondly on the palate. The salads also deserve mention—the Baby Spinach with Goat Cheese, Bacon Crisps, Raisins, and Balsamic Vinaigrette provides a crisp, refreshing counterpoint to the rich, savory mains.

What truly sets Max and Leo's apart is not just the food but the warm, welcoming atmosphere and service that accompanies it. Past visitors often praise the friendly and attentive staff, especially Tess, a server who manages the bustling eatery with charm and grace. The owner’s genuine hospitality makes every guest feel like part of the family, creating an inviting environment perfect for everything from casual lunches to cozy nights out.

Regulars and newcomers alike highlight the restaurant’s authenticity and quality. One Boston traveler from Florida was so impressed by the impeccable pizzas and attentive service that she vowed a return visit. Another local food lover described their crust as "absolutely perfect," recommending the veggie and Margherita pizzas as must-tries. The intimate size of the location only adds to the charm, fostering a personal feel and ensuring every dish is served fresh and piping hot.

In short, Max and Leo's Pizza Newton captures the essence of artisanal pizza-making balanced by thoughtful menus and impeccable service. Whether you’re craving a hearty pie, legendary wings, or a quick flavorful bite, this neighborhood treasure promises a memorable and delicious experience every time.

Location: 325 Washington St, Newton, MA 02458
Phone: +1 617-244-7200